Skip to Content
Remaining Ad Time Ad - 00:00

Former prosecutor: Winning conviction in Columbia police manslaughter case could be difficult

Columbia police officer Andria Heese is charged with involuntary manslaughter in a child's death.
ABC 17 News
Columbia police officer Andria Heese is charged with involuntary manslaughter in a child's death.


A former Cole County prosecutor said Wednesday that getting a conviction against a law enforcement officer is "immensely difficult."

"It's not common to have convictions of law enforcement without some pretty damning evidence," Bill Tackett said.

Prosecutors this week charged Columbia Police Department Officer Andria Heese with involuntary manslaughter in the death of 4-year-old Gabriella Curry. Charging documents made public Tuesday allege Heese was acting recklessly when she ran over the child.

Heese hit and killed Curry on Jan. 4 in her patrol vehicle. According to crash reports, the officer was trying to park on the sidewalk at Battle High School so she could watch students load onto school buses.

According to court documents, multiple witnesses say and security footage show Heese getting out of her vehicle, preforming CPR on the child and calling for help.

The Missouri State Highway Patrol investigated the crash before handing its findings over to Camden County Prosecuting Attorney Heather Miller, who filed the manslaughter charge. Tackett says a judge will likely be appointed from outside of Boone County as well.

"All of this circuit will recuse themselves because they've all dealt with CPD," Tackett said. "You'll have a different judge, a different jury."

If the case makes it to trial, that could come with more issues for the prosecution, Tackett said.

"The jury selection would be extremely time-consuming because you're talking about prosecuting a police officer who, at least publicly, has shown a tremendous amount of remorse," Tackett said.

The complaint against Heese says she ran the girl over "after entering an area typically used by pedestrians at a speed and coming from an angle which prevented her from avoiding" Curry.

Miller on Tuesday declined to elaborate on why Heese's actions were reckless, citing the ongoing prosecution.

Missouri statutes define acting recklessly as when a person "consciously disregards a substantial and unjustifiable risk that circumstances exist or that a result will follow, and such disregard constitutes a gross deviation from the standard of care which a reasonable person would exercise in the situation."

"They would be trying to determine whether it was just an accident, or if there was something reckless that occurred and that's a steep hill to climb," Tackett said.

Involuntary manslaughter carries a maximum sentence of 10 years in prison. Heese could receive probation if found guilty of the crime.

Heese's attorney, Donald Weaver, declined to comment for this story.

City of Columbia spokesman Steve Sapp deferred questions about whether Heese had been arrested or made arrangements to turn herself in to the Missouri State Highway Patrol and the special prosecutor. Online court records show she has a $5,000 bond and that Weaver filed an entry of appearance on Tuesday.

Check back or watch ABC 17 News at 5 for more on this developing story.

Columbia / Court and Trials / Homicide / News / Top Stories

Connor Hirsch

Connor Hirsch reports for the weekday night shows, as well as Sunday nights.



  1. What’s not reckless about driving into a sidewalk? Btw, talking to someone who fixed a ticket for his brother and misused tax dollars about their legal opinion is like asking a poacher about game laws.

  2. This was a unfortunate accident that this officer will live with for the rest of her life, the parking on the sidewalk was a everyday procedure I pass by there often, possibly not the best idea in hindsight but it happened. I can see nothing good coming out of prosecution of this officer and don’t think it will make anyone feel any better, all it will accomplish is running up a lot of attorney fees and further the anguish, it should be dropped in my opinion.

    1. Just because it was done every day doesn’t make it any less reckless. Ask any idiot on the street if sidewalks are made for walking on or driving on, what do you think tbe answer would be?

  3. Reckless, is letting a four year old child, wander unsupervised, around a high school bus loading area, filled with fourty foot long busses. The charges should be dropped immediately, and whom ever filed these charges, should be fired.

      1. The child was on the sidewalk, not wondering around on the driveway.
        It was a stupid policy to allow ANYONE to drive/park on a sidewalk. Get out of your vehicle and stand and watch the kids getting on the bus.

Leave a Reply

Skip to content